W. Joseph Campbell

No ‘rock-em,’ no ‘sock-em': What ails WaPo

In Debunking, Jessica Lynch, Media myths, Newspapers, Washington Post, Watergate myth on August 7, 2011 at 1:59 am

The ombudsman of the Washington Post, Patrick Pexton, weighs in today with platitudes and hang-wringing about the newspaper. He mostly misses the mark.

Pexton writes in his column that the Post’s “future lies not with the rich; it lies with the citizenry.

“This newspaper must be the one source of high-quality, probing Washington news that readers in this region and across the country can look to for holding their government accountable. This publication must be for all Americans.”

Oh, brother.

But wait: Here’s more vague abstraction:

“The Post,” Pexton writes, “can’t be a liberal publication or a conservative one. It must be hard-hitting, scrappy and questioning — skeptical of all political figures and parties and beholden to no one. It has to be the rock-’em-sock-’em organization that is passionate about the news. It needs to be less bloodless and take more risks when chasing the story and the truth.”

A “rock-’em-sock-’em organization,” eh? Well, that’s useful guidance.

In his five or so months as ombudsman, Pexton hasn’t dared touch the electrified third rail about the Post, which one of his predecessors, Deborah Howell, gamely if belatedly addressed.

That’s a decided lack of intellectual diversity in the Post’s newsroom. In mid-November 2008, shortly after Barack Obama was elected president, Howell wrote in her ombudsman column:

“I’ll bet that most Post journalists voted for Obama. I did. There are centrists at The Post as well. But the conservatives I know here feel so outnumbered that they don’t even want to be quoted by name in a memo.”

Howell’s column quoted Tom Rosenstiel of the Project for Excellence in Journalism as saying that “conservatives are right that journalism has too many liberals and not enough conservatives. It’s inconceivable that that is irrelevant.”

In Obama's thrall

The lack of intellectual diversity often shows in the Post’s report. Even casual reading signals that the newspaper remains in the thrall of Obama, despite his clearly failing presidency.

Obama scarcely gets “rock-’em-sock-’em” treatment from the Post.

Last Wednesday, for example, the Post’s once-edgy “Style” section devoted most of its front page to a cheery feature about the meaning of Obama’s turning 50-years-old.

“On Thursday,” the article gushed, “President Obama — one of American history’s most precocious achievers — joins the ranks of Washington 50-somethings ….”

But what ails the Post goes well beyond its routinely tender treatment of Obama.

The Post’s local report is superficial, a diet of eye-rolling, feel-good features. The newspaper carries little staff-produced national coverage. Its international report is undistinguished, especially compared to that of the New York Times.

Moreover, the Post offers few notable cases of investigative journalism any more.

It has won two Pulitzer Prizes for investigative reporting in 25 years, which has to be considered meager for a newspaper that reputedly brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt presidency with its relentless digging into the Watergate scandal.

But as I discuss in my latest book, Getting It Wrong, the Post-Watergate trope, of course, is a powerful media-driven myth.

I’d be remiss were I to fail to note that the Post never has come clean about how it erred so utterly in offering the world the bogus hero-warrior tale about Jessica Lynch in the early days of the Iraq War.

Lynch, the Post reported on its front page on April 3, 2003, “fought fiercely and shot several enemy soldiers after Iraqi forces ambushed the Army’s 507th Ordnance Maintenance Company, firing her weapon until she ran out of ammunition, U.S. officials said yesterday.”

But none of the derring-do attributed to Lynch was true, and the Post has never explained who led it so badly astray.

Moreover, the staff cuts and buyouts of recent years left few notable characters on the newspaper’s staff.

Gone are such colorful figures as the erudite and pugnacious Henry Allen, a Pulitzer winner who left the Post after throwing punches at a staff writer who called him a c—sucker.

Now there was “rock-’em-sock-’em,” old school variety.


Many thanks to Instapundit
Glenn Reynolds for linking to this post.

Recent and related:

About these ads
  1. [...] JOSEPH CAMPBELL: No ‘rock-em,’ no ‘sock-em’: What ails WaPo. “The ombudsman of the Washington Post, Patrick Pexton, weighs in today with platitudes and [...]

  2. [...] his Media Myth Alert blog, W. Joseph Campbell has some fun with the Washington Post’s latest ombudsman, who’s ready to switch his Rock-’em Sock-’em Robot toys into full-on automatic [...]

  3. [...] two nice columns devoted to The Washington Post‘s attempt to adopt The Macho Response, one by W. Joseph Campbell (check the “W” – not the late NewAge guy) and one by Ed Driscoll, but both are [...]

  4. [...] line, of course, is “follow the money,” which purportedly was crucial advice given the Washington Post by a super-secret, high-level source code-named “Deep [...]

  5. [...] is the line to be found in All the President’s Men, the book Woodward and his Post colleague, Carl Bernstein, wrote about their Watergate [...]

  6. [...] fails to identify the Washington Post as solely responsible for placing the hero-warrior tale about Lynch into worldwide [...]

  7. [...] — and overstating — the accomplishments of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, the Washington Post reporters who covered the [...]

  8. [...] Everything Changed,” the Washington Post declares on its front page [...]

  9. [...] Washington Post flatly asserted recently that Jefferson “fathered children with his slave Sally [...]

  10. [...] though, not even the Washington Post embraces the heroic-journalist [...]

  11. [...] “the endlessly appealing notion that the dogged reporting of two young, hungry, and tireless Washington Post journalists, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, brought down Nixon and his corrupt presidency” [...]

  12. [...] “follow the money” appeared in no Watergate-related article or editorial in the Washington Post  before 1981 — or long after Nixon resigned the presidency in [...]

  13. [...] The heroic-journalist narrative has it that Richard Nixon’s corrupt presidency was brought down through the reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post. [...]

  14. [...] Even “immortal.”  But “Deep Throat” never told Woodward, he of the Washington Post, to “follow the [...]

  15. [...] which gave rise to the greatest scandal in U.S. politics — and to the media-driven myth that Washington Post journalists toppled a president. Woodward: 40th anniversary [...]

  16. [...] Washington Post – the newspaper that brought the world the bogus hero-warrior tale about Jessica Lynch early [...]

  17. [...] Washington Post – the newspaper that brought the world the bogus hero-warrior tale about Jessica Lynch early in [...]

  18. [...] So now, how about some transparency from the Washington Post? [...]

  19. [...] No ‘rock-em,’ no ‘sock-em’: What ails WaPo? [...]

  20. [...] passage in a recent  essay at a Washington Post blog demonstrates just how insidious the notion is that the military made up the hero-warrior tale [...]

  21. [...] email today, I asked Patrick Pexton, the Post’s ombudsman or reader’s representative, if he knew how or why the two versions of the same story differed [...]

  22. [...] was she shot, as the Post reported. She suffered shattering injuries in the crash of the [...]

  23. [...] this case, the embarrassment quotient remains high enough for the Post to identify its Lynch sources — if not by name, then by [...]

  24. [...] a safe bet that many of the tributes to the Post and its Watergate reporting team of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein will be exaggerated and [...]

  25. [...] Washington Post carried a fine story yesterday about Vogue magazine’s apparent removal from its online site [...]

  26. [...] weeks ago, the Washington Post ombudsman promised to look into questions I had posed about the unavailable digital versions of the [...]

  27. [...] to read the Washington Post article of April 10, 2003, about the fall of Baghdad to U.S. forces? The article’s online [...]

  28. [...] in Washington of the Democratic National Committee. This installment discusses the notion that the Washington Post “uncovered” the Watergate story. Post’s Watergate story, June 18, 1972 (Ransom Center, [...]

  29. [...] ombudsman, Patrick Pexton, urged the Post and other news organizations “to seek out and cover the unconventional and outsider voices [...]

  30. [...] of WaPo’s online content about Jessica Lynch (posted April 27): On April 4, 2003, the Washington Post published a front-page report about an Iraqi lawyer who helped set in motion the rescue from [...]

  31. [...] Sunday “Outlook” section of the Washington Post usually is such a jumble of thumbsucker essays and middling book reviews that it deserves just [...]

  32. [...] that the Washington Post is exploring the sale of its headquarters building inevitably stirred reminders of the Watergate [...]

  33. [...] more, principals at the Washington Post have from time to time over the years dismissed the notion that the newspaper was central in [...]

  34. [...] principals at the Post have over the years similarly dismissed such outsize [...]

  35. [...] Washington Post today offers one of the more baffling and illogical characterizations of the supposed effects of [...]

  36. [...] “Power Player” segment featured Martin Baron, who’s been executive editor of the Washington Post for a little more than three months. It was a fair-minded look at a respected, veteran journalist; [...]

  37. [...] reporting set the table for the crucial official inquiries — is favored by the Post (its Web site explains Watergate that [...]

  38. […] scandal that unfolded 40 years ago. But it’s an inaccurate interpretation; not even the Washington Post embraces it, as I point out in my mythbusting book, Getting It […]

  39. […] the Post fumbled that story makes for an intriguing sidebar at the anniversary of Butterfield’s stunning disclosure. The […]

  40. […] Post said in the obituary that Thomas had once “asked President Richard M. Nixon point-blank” about […]

  41. […] Post said in the obituary that Thomas once “asked President Richard M. Nixon point-blank” about […]

  42. […] No ‘rock-em,’ no ‘sock-em’: What ails WaPo […]

  43. […] sale of the Washington Post closed Tuesday; the new owner is Jeff Bezos, who in July 1995 began selling books at Amazon.com, in […]

  44. […] was often outstanding in five years as ombudsman at the Washington Post, notably calling out the newspaper’s botched reporting about Jessica Lynch’s mythical […]

  45. […] clear error on Nixon’s mythical ‘secret plan’ (posted August 13):  Even in its clear decline, the Washington Post can be an arrogant news […]

  46. […] No ‘rock-em,’ no ‘sock-em’: What ails WaPo […]

  47. […] Maddow failed to mention the foundation of the bogus hero-warrior story – the Washington Post article that cited “U.S. officials” in saying that Lynch, then a 19-year-old supply […]

  48. […] parking garage in suburban Virginia where Washington Post reporter Bob Woodward occasionally met with his stealthy Watergate source “Deep Throat” […]

  49. […] example, the Watergate myth — that the reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post brought down Richard Nixon’s corrupt presidency — is so hardy. It’s easy to grasp […]

  50. […] Washington Post brought together its legendary Watergate reporters last night for a lengthy look back at the scandal […]

  51. […] that Jeff Bezos is ousting the publisher of the Washington Post about a year after he purchased the newspaper prompted recollections of the Post’s better […]

  52. […] — the mistaken notion that the dogged reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post brought down the corrupt presidency of Richard M. Nixon in […]

  53. […] of a full-text database of leading U.S. newspapers in 1968 — among them the New York Times, Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, Wall Street Journal, and Chicago Tribune. The search terms […]

  54. […] the mythical and simplistic notion that the reporting of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein for the Washington Post brought down Richard M. Nixon’s corrupt presidency — is one of those rare tales that […]

  55. […] a full-text database of leading U.S. newspapers in 1968 — among them the New York Times, Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, Wall Street Journal, and Chicago Tribune. The search terms […]

Comments are closed.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,759 other followers

%d bloggers like this: